Friend et al. v. Newsom
Summary
California Supreme Court case in which the Criminal Justice Legal Foundation (CJLF), on behalf of victims and their families, elected district attorneys, law enforcement leaders and organizations, and victims’ rights organizations, challenges Governor Gavin Newsom’s unprecedented effort to commute 548 death sentences. In March 2019, Governor Newsom issued an executive order imposing a moratorium on executions in California, while expressly leaving existing death sentences intact. On November 5, 2026, the Governor announced his intention to commute all remaining death sentences, despite California voters having twice rejected efforts to abolish the death penalty and having approved Proposition 66 in 2016 to reform and expedite the death penalty process.
CJLF filed a petition for writ of mandate in the California Supreme Court challenging the Governor’s failure to comply with constitutional and statutory requirements governing executive clemency. The petition argues that the Governor failed to provide legally required notice to district attorneys, thereby depriving victims and their families of their constitutional rights to be notified and heard. Many victims’ families learned of the Governor’s plans through the news rather than from the government entrusted to protect their rights.
The petition also challenges the Governor’s abuse of executive clemency power in predetermining the outcome for hundreds of condemned murderers without conducting meaningful individualized reviews. Under the California Constitution, the Governor cannot commute the sentence of a person twice convicted of a felony without the recommendation of the California Supreme Court, with four justices concurring. The Governor’s reliance on criminal history summaries to identify these individuals raises serious concerns about the accuracy of his classifications and the adequacy of the information provided to the Court. Investigations by district attorneys have already identified discrepancies in criminal history records, including errors concerning prior felony convictions.
CJLF argues that the Governor’s clemency authority, while broad, is not unlimited and does not permit him to circumvent constitutional safeguards, statutory requirements, victims’ rights or the California Supreme Court’s independent constitutional role. The petition seeks to prevent the Governor from proceeding with the blanket commutations in violation of these requirements.
[Filed: Nov. 15, 2026. Read the Petition for Writ of Mandate with the link below. The exhibit link: https://cjlf.org/ClemencyWritExhibitsDeclarations.]
